Covering Violence
A Guide to Ethical Reporting about Victims & Trauma
Second Edition (2006)
By Roger Simpson & William Coté
Roger Simpson was the founding director of the Dart Center
for Journalism and Trauma at the University of Washington
and is on the faculty of the Department of Communication,
where he is the Dart Professor of Journalism and Trauma.
He has co-authored two books on Pacific Northwest social and
labor history, and has been a reporter for The Wall Street
Journal and The Detroit Free Press.
William Coté is emeritus professor of journalism at
Michigan State University, where he was the coordinator of
the Victims and the Media Program. For almost twenty
years he was a professional journalist at the Ypsilanti
Press and Booth Newspapers State Capitol Bureau.
“We had been newspaper reporters and had covered a
wide range of news events, but we matured as journalists without
knowing much about what the victims in our stories truly experienced,”
Roger Simpson and William Coté write in the preface
to the second edition of this comprehensive guide to how to
cover violence, report on victims with respect, and recognize
the effects of emotional injury on both journalists and those
they cover.
The new edition reflects on the events that have commanded
media attention in recent years, the Columbine High School
shootings, the 2004 tsunami, Gulf hurricanes, 9-11, and the
Iraq war while keeping a sharp focus on the forms of violence
that journalists in any community must face regularly -- interpersonal
cruelty, traffic deaths and injuries, and natural disasters.
The book includes special profiles of nine journalists and
examples of their reporting or photography. The profiles,
written by Migael Scherer, a Seattle educator, and John Harris,
a journalism professor at Western Washington University, include
Sonia Nazario, a Pulitzer-winning reporter for the Los Angeles
Times; Fletcher Johnson, photographer for ABC News; Jane Hansen,
an Atlanta Journal-Constitution reporter specializing in children’s
issues; Marley Shebala, reporter for the Navajo Times; Anh
Do, a journalist with the Orange County Register; Sharon Schmickle,
who reported from Iraq for the Minneapolis Star-Tribune; New
York Daily News photographer David Handschuh; Debra McKinney,
a social-concerns reporter for the Anchorage Daily News, and
Scott North, a courts reporter for The Herald in Everett,
Washington.
The book presents innovative ways of interviewing and photographing
survivors of violence and helps journalists understand the
effects of frequent exposure to traumatic events on their
own lives. The authors relate journalistic practices
to the rapidly expanding body of literature on trauma, and
draw on the insights of clinical experts.
A new chapter of Guidelines for Journalists Who Cover Violence
and suggestions for training news staffs or journalism students
give the book value in newsrooms and college classrooms.
“Since 9-11, write Simpson and Coté, we have
witnessed a renewed commitment to sensitive, insightful reporting
about trauma. We want to see more news that conveys
in ethical words and images the experience of people who suffer
harm. We have been moved to write these chapters because
so many journalists we know express the same hope.”
The Journalists
The new Second Edition of Covering Violence
adds profiles of seven new photojournalists and reporters,
and samples of their work, to the profiles of reporters Scott
North and Debra McKinney retained from the First Edition.
The profiles were written by Migael Scherer, a Seattle educator,
and John Harris, a professor of journalism at Western Washington
University in Bellingham..
Sharon Schmickle
"Sharon Schmickle wasn't sure what she would write about
when she arrived in Kuwait in February 2003. She was there
as a war correspondent for the Minneapolis Star Tribune,
but she'd never covered a war."
David Handschuh
David Handschuh "was headed to New York University that
morning to teach a photojournalism class and, as always, had
the police and fire radios chattering away in his car. He
spotted smoke billowing into the blue sky above Lower Manhattan,
and a moment later a fire dispatcher yelled for all available
apparatus to head downtown."
Marley Shebala
"Marley Shebala's Navajo Times colleague showed
her a photograph he had taken of a blood-soaked mop at the
scene of a domestic dispute. A man had beaten his wife and
then ordered their teen-age son to mop up the blood."
Anh Do
"A video-store owner displayed a communist flag and
a portrait of Ho Chi Minh in his shop in Orange County, California's
'Little Saigon' in 1999. Intended as a gesture of support
for better relations with the Vietnamese government, the display
sparked daily demonstrations by hundreds of Vietnamese Americans,
and the shop owner was hospitalized after protesters attacked
him. The scope and fury of the response surprised many in
Orange County, but Anh Do, a reporter for the Orange County
Register, understood what lay behind it."
Sonia Nazario
"'One of the things I do as a reporter is emphathize,'
explains Sonia Nazario of the Los Angeles Times.
'It helps me to get inside their heads.' For her Pulitzer
Prize series, 'Enrique's Journey,' her empathy went beyond
sensitive questions, careful listening, and sharing control.
In order to write about the dangerous journey made by thousands
of Central American children desperate to enter the United
States in order to reunite with their mothers, she joined
them."
Fletcher Johnson
"Fletcher Johnson has seen his share of violence and
trauma in twenty years as a news photographer for ABC News.
He covered the second intifada in the Middle East, the war
in Kosovo, and the war in Iraq. He points to two assignments
early in his career that left an indelible impression on him
and helped prepare him for the stories he later would cover."
Jane O. Hansen
"In January 2001 readers of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution
opened their Sunday paper to the front-page story written
by Jane O. Hansen, "Selling Atlanta's Children."
As the deck bluntly explained, 'Runaway girls lured into the
sex trade are being jailed for crimes while their adult pimps
go free.' The photo, placed prominently above the fold, was
stunning and unforgettable: the shackled ankles of a ten-year-old
girl."
Debra McKinney
"Getting on with their lives. Putting the pieces back
together again. With 'Malignant Memories,' Anchorage Daily
News reporter Debra McKinney transcends these clichés
to give readers an honest look at recovery from childhood
sexual abuse."
Scott North
"'A murder is an important part of a community's history,'
says Scott North of the Herald in Everett, Washington.
'Putting it and the life that was taken into context requires
time.'"
|